{% extends "base.html" %}
{% from "_help.html" import info %}
{% from "_job_status.html" import job_status %}
{% block title %}Critique — Paperful{% endblock %}
{% block body_attrs %}{% if poll_run %} data-poll-run="{{ poll_run }}"{% endif %}{% endblock %}
{% block content %}
<h1>Critique</h1>
<p class="page-lede">A local pre-submission / reading-aid pack. Deterministic checkers always run. Optional review lanes (reviewers, MARG-S, adversary, claims, verify, context) are separate <em>suggested</em> extras and can run together. There is no score, grade, or accept/reject. Uploads stay under <code>state/critiques/uploads/</code> and are not written to <code>out/</code> or Zotero.</p>
{% if error == 'target' %}<div class="error-banner">Pick a library item <em>or</em> upload a file, not both and not neither.</div>{% endif %}
{% if error == 'format' %}<div class="error-banner">That file type is not supported. Use pdf, txt, md, html, rtf, docx, odt, pptx (legacy .doc needs a converter on PATH).</div>{% endif %}
{% if error == 'size' %}<div class="error-banner">The upload is larger than 40 MB.</div>{% endif %}
{% if error and error not in ('target', 'format', 'size') %}<div class="error-banner">{{ error }}</div>{% endif %}

{{ job_status(run_rec, 'Critique') }}

<section class="panel">
  <h2>Library item</h2>
  <p class="section-lede">Scope follows the collection chip. Overlap and “cited but not in library” use that collection’s extracted text when <code>state/rag/text/</code> exists.</p>
  <form method="post" action="/critique" class="toolbar" enctype="multipart/form-data">
    <label>Item {{ info("A paper already mirrored under out/. --item on the CLI.") }}
      <select name="item_key">
        <option value="">Choose an item</option>
        {% for it in items %}
        <option value="{{ it.key }}">{{ it.title }}{% if it.year %} ({{ it.year }}){% endif %} — {{ it.key }}</option>
        {% endfor %}
      </select>
    </label>
    {% if llm_on %}
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="reviewers"{% if "reviewers" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Reviewers {{ info("Suggested lane. Grounded in the manuscript text and checked findings. Needs [llm].enabled. Independent [[critique.reviewers]] calls. Additive with other review lanes.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="marg"{% if "marg" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> MARG-S multi-agent {{ info("MARG-S-style groups (experiments, clarity, impact) plus a refine pass. Suggested lane. Additive with other review lanes. Needs [llm].enabled. Inspired by D’Arcy et al.; Paperful does not vendor that repo.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="adversary"{% if "adversary" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Adversary (validity red-team) {{ info("Structured validity attacks: alternative explanations, selection/construct/external validity, researcher degrees of freedom, falsifiers, missing negative cases. Suggested lane. Additive. Needs [llm].enabled. No score or accept/reject.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="claims"{% if "claims" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Claims (intra-doc ledger) {{ info("Extract core claims and bind them to methods/results/limitations spans in this extract. Status is support in the text, not a truth verdict. Suggested lane. Needs [llm].enabled.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="verify"{% if "verify" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Verify (section swarm) {{ info("Segment the manuscript, spend more compute on dense proof/methods sections, then synthesize with local grounding. Not Deep Review and not a hosted upload. Suggested lane. Needs [llm].enabled.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="context"{% if "context" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Context (library) {{ info("ScholarPeer-inspired: summary, library historian, baseline scout, Q&A. Local RAG / extract only. No live web. Suggested lane.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="context-web"{% if "context-web" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Context (web) {{ info("Same pipeline as Context (library), plus opt-in OpenAlex / SearXNG. Literature metadata leaves this machine. Off unless you tick it. Suggested lane.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="grobid" value="1"{% if grobid_enabled %} checked{% endif %}> GROBID sidecar {{ info("Section-labeled chunks for MARG-S, claims, and verify. Needs [grobid].enabled and a reachable server, or a warm TEI cache. Scans need OCR first. Remote hosts send PDF bytes off this machine. Checkers still use ExtractedDoc.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="force" value="1"> Force LLM {{ info("Run suggested comments even when identity lint flagged the PDF.") }}</label>
    {% endif %}
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="ai_model" value="1"> AI model {{ info("Optional Binoculars extra. Paperful does not install torch. Missing extra records ai_model_unavailable. Not proof of authorship.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="vale" value="1"> Vale {{ info("Optional house-style pass. Not pre-checked. Needs vale on PATH and [critique].vale_config (or .vale.ini next to the paperful config). Missing extra records vale_unavailable / vale_no_config / vale_failed. Also runs when [critique].vale is true.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="forensics" value="1"> Forensics (PaperGuard) {{ info("Optional subprocess scan. Not a lane. Needs paperguard on PATH. Findings are suggested anomalies to investigate, not a misconduct verdict. Missing extra records paperguard_unavailable. Also runs when [critique].forensics is true.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="apply" value="1"> Write child note {{ info("Library item only. Tagged paperful-critique. Uploads stay disk-only.", danger=true) }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="show_dismissed" value="1"> Show dismissed {{ info("Include findings you previously dismissed in pack.md.") }}</label>
    <button type="submit">Critique item</button>
    {{ info("Writes state/critiques/<item-key>/<stamp>/pack.json and pack.md. Does not fetch or attach.") }}
  </form>
  {% if not items %}
  <p class="section-lede">No items in the current collection chip. Set a collection on Library, or upload a draft below.</p>
  {% endif %}
</section>

<section class="panel">
  <h2>Upload a draft</h2>
  <p class="section-lede">Drop a manuscript you have not imported. The copy stays under <code>state/critiques/uploads/</code>. It is never a Zotero parent and never lands in <code>out/</code>.</p>
  <form method="post" action="/critique" class="toolbar" enctype="multipart/form-data">
    <label class="drop-zone">Drop a draft (pdf, docx, odt, html, rtf, txt, md, pptx) or choose a file
      <input type="file" name="file" accept="{{ accept }}">
    </label>
    {% if llm_on %}
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="reviewers"{% if "reviewers" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Reviewers {{ info("Suggested lane. Grounded in the uploaded text and checked findings. Additive with other review lanes.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="marg"{% if "marg" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> MARG-S multi-agent {{ info("MARG-S-style groups. Suggested lane. Additive with other review lanes.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="adversary"{% if "adversary" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Adversary (validity red-team) {{ info("Structured validity attacks. Suggested lane. Additive with other review lanes.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="claims"{% if "claims" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Claims (intra-doc ledger) {{ info("Bind core claims to methods/results/limitations spans in this extract. Not a truth verdict.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="verify"{% if "verify" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Verify (section swarm) {{ info("Segment-and-verify with density budgets and local grounding. Not Deep Review.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="context"{% if "context" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Context (library) {{ info("ScholarPeer-inspired local historian / scout / Q&A. No live web.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="lane" value="context-web"{% if "context-web" in critique_lanes %} checked{% endif %}> Context (web) {{ info("Same as Context (library) plus OpenAlex / SearXNG. Literature metadata leaves this machine.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="grobid" value="1"{% if grobid_enabled %} checked{% endif %}> GROBID sidecar {{ info("Section-labeled chunks for MARG-S, claims, and verify. PDFs only. Remote hosts send PDF bytes off this machine.") }}</label>
    {% endif %}
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="ai_model" value="1"> AI model {{ info("Optional Binoculars extra. Missing extra records ai_model_unavailable. Not proof of authorship.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="vale" value="1"> Vale {{ info("Optional house-style pass. Not pre-checked. Needs vale on PATH and a .vale.ini. Missing extra records vale_unavailable / vale_no_config / vale_failed. Also runs when [critique].vale is true.") }}</label>
    <label><input type="checkbox" name="forensics" value="1"> Forensics (PaperGuard) {{ info("Optional subprocess scan. Needs paperguard on PATH. Suggested anomalies to investigate, not a grade. Missing extra records paperguard_unavailable. Also runs when [critique].forensics is true.") }}</label>
    <button type="submit">Critique file</button>
    {{ info("Same checkers as --file. Collection chip is the overlap corpus when text is already cached.") }}
  </form>
</section>

{% if result and result.counts %}
<section class="panel">
  <h2>This pack</h2>
  <p>Findings: {{ result.findings or result.counts.findings or 0 }}
    {% if result.critique_id %}· id <code>{{ result.critique_id }}</code>{% endif %}
    {% if result.applied %}· child note written{% endif %}
  </p>
  {% if pack_md %}
  <pre class="pack-md">{{ pack_md }}</pre>
  {% endif %}
</section>
{% endif %}

{% if recent %}
<section class="panel">
  <h2>Recent packs</h2>
  <p class="section-lede">On disk under <code>state/critiques/</code>. Dismiss findings with <code>paperful critique dismiss ID</code>.</p>
  <table class="wb-table">
    <thead><tr><th>Title</th><th>Id</th><th>Findings</th><th>Stamp</th></tr></thead>
    <tbody>
    {% for row in recent %}
      <tr>
        <td>{{ row.title }}</td>
        <td><code>{{ row.critique_id }}</code></td>
        <td>{{ row.findings }}</td>
        <td>{{ row.stamp }}</td>
      </tr>
    {% endfor %}
    </tbody>
  </table>
</section>
{% endif %}
{% endblock %}