RESEARCH CHANGE REVIEW

PaperDelta.

See where a result is used. Review what changed.

7confirmed
1pass
6mismatch
0unknown

Consistency with supplied results · baseline: before
0 unbound numeric candidates · 0 unsupported regions · 0 unregistered figure references

Metric changes

MetricChangeBeforeAfterUnit
ourschanged0.8410.809fraction
gainchanged3.100-0.100percentage points

Where each result is used

baseline 0.810 fraction

results/metrics.csv · History: unchanged

Findings

error · CLAIM_FALSE · paper/results.tex:17

The confirmed comparison no longer holds for the selected evidence

Our method outperforms Baseline on Data-A.

Review the affected claim against its evidence. Related numeric fixes remain blocked until the claim holds.

Show evidence

ours 0.809 fraction

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=10.807line 2
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=20.809line 3
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=30.811line 4

baseline 0.810 fraction

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=10.809line 5
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=20.810line 6
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=30.811line 7
error · VALUE_MISMATCH · paper/abstract.tex:2

'84.1\\%' should display '80.9\\%' from metric ours

84.1\%
84.1\% → 80.9\%

Review the related claim before applying numeric fixes: claim:main_comparison

Compare the source records with the highlighted replacement and preview the patch.

Show evidence

ours 0.809 fraction

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=10.807line 2
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=20.809line 3
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=30.811line 4
error · VALUE_MISMATCH · paper/results.tex:8

'84.1' should display '80.9' from metric ours

84.1
84.1 → 80.9

Review the related claim before applying numeric fixes: claim:main_comparison

Compare the source records with the highlighted replacement and preview the patch.

Show evidence

ours 0.809 fraction

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=10.807line 2
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=20.809line 3
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=30.811line 4
error · VALUE_MISMATCH · paper/results.tex:16

'3.1' should display '-0.1' from metric gain

3.1
3.1 → -0.1

Review the related claim before applying numeric fixes: claim:main_comparison

Compare the source records with the highlighted replacement and preview the patch.

Show evidence

gain -0.100 percentage points

Calculation: percentage_point_difference(ours, baseline)

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=10.807line 2
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=20.809line 3
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=30.811line 4

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=10.809line 5
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=20.810line 6
dataset=Data-A; model=Baseline; split=test; seed=30.811line 7
error · VALUE_MISMATCH · paper/appendix.tex:4

'84.1' should display '80.9' from metric ours

84.1
84.1 → 80.9

Review the related claim before applying numeric fixes: claim:main_comparison

Compare the source records with the highlighted replacement and preview the patch.

Show evidence

ours 0.809 fraction

results/metrics.csv · mean of 3 records

Field: accuracy · dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test

Record identityValueLocation
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=10.807line 2
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=20.809line 3
dataset=Data-A; model=Ours; split=test; seed=30.811line 4
error · FIGURE_CHANGED · figure:accuracy

Recorded identities changed: ['results/metrics.csv']

Inspect the changed dependencies, regenerate the figure if needed, and record its current inputs.

Show evidence

Record method: imported

Changed declared dependencies

  • results/metrics.csv

Coverage

Unbound candidates and unsupported regions are outside confirmed checks. Grouping retains every recorded occurrence.

Unbound numeric candidates (0)

None recorded.

Unsupported regions (0)

None recorded.

Unregistered figure references (0)

None recorded.