Year [1]Seniors (Trood Award & Rodda Medal) Reserves (Rex Hartley Medal) Under 18's (Bruce Wilkinson Medal) Under 16's (Shaw/Carter Medal)
1954 CollingwoodDesign.svg Bob Mason (Sale) (20 Votes) Rex Donnelly (Moe) (19)
1955 CollingwoodDesign.svg Bob Mason (Sale) (23) Ron Hayes (Warragul) (20)
1956 Traralgondesign.png Noel Alford (Traralgon) (18) "Mossy" Morgan (Trafalgar) (33)
1957 CollingwoodDesign.svg John Nix (Sale) (21) "Mossy" Morgan (Trafalgar) (16) M.James (Morwell) (19)
1958 Moewglfl.PNG Lester Ross (Moe) (31) Tom Hart (Sale) (33) M.West (Warragul) (14)
1959 Peter Bevilacqua (Yarragon) (19) Ray Pollock (Yallourn) N.Hall (Yallourn) (12)
1960 Steve Szabo (Morwell) (20) Allan Rankin (Trafalgar) (20) G.Townsend (St Pat's) (22)
1961 EssendonDesign.svg Kevin Coverdale (Bairnsdale) (24) Jack Vinall (Yallourn) (20) G.Townsend (St Pat's) (31)
1962 EssendonDesign.svg Ric Belford (Yallourn) (27) Tom O'Callaghan (Traralgon) (18) T.Hunter (Traralgon) (29)
1963 Moewglfl.PNG Allan Steele (Moe) (18) Ron Serong (Warragul) (32) R.Foster (St Pat's A) (35) WEST ZONE (Under 18's)
1964 EssendonDesign.svg Mike Collins (Yallourn) (17) Max Prendergast (Bairnsdale) (27) J.Barnett (Sale) (23) B.Pickering (Trar. Colts) (12)
1965 Steve Szabo (Morwell) (26) Richard Evans (Maffra) (20) J.Barnett (Sale) (25) P.Lerstang (Traraglon Colts) (23)
1966 Traralgondesign.png Terry Hunter (Traralgon) (15) Les Roberts (Sale) (21) G.Fletcher (St Pat's) (20) C.Luxford (Morwell) (18)
1967 Traralgondesign.png George Brayshaw (Traralgon) (15) Les Roberts (Sale) (12) D.Scott (Heyfield) (23) R.Baldry (Warragul) (12)
1968 MelbourneHeartColours.png Les Hawken (Trafalgar) (31) Peter Rodaughan (Moe) (28) J.Welsh (St Pat's) (30) E.Gray (Trar. Colts) (25)
1969 EssendonDesign.svg John Gallus (Bairnsdale) (37) Barry Taylor (Yallourn) (14) P.Speed (Sale) (22) M.Mancuso (Traralgon) (11)
1970 Mafwglfl.PNG John Gallus (Maffra) (30) Lyle Berry (Heyfield) (18) A.Gallagher (St Pat's) (27) G.McFarlane (Morwell) (13)
1971 Leowglfl.PNG Terry Benton (Leongatha) (20) Graeme Anderson (Heyfield) (18) I.Stanley (Traralgon) (19) P.Shields (Moe) (15)
1972 Henro Kornacki (Morwell) (27) Barry Taylor (Yallourn) (13) T.Munro (Traralgon) (23) L.Ponton (Trar. Colts) (18)
1973 Moewglfl.PNG Barry Rowlings (Moe) (35) Jack Vardy (Maffra) (21) A.Williams (Traralgon) (19) C.Carr (Morwell) (18)
1974 Moewglfl.PNG Barry Rowlings (Moe) (28) Gus Eaton (Moe) (20) J.Buntine (Sale) (24) S.McNamara (Leongatha) (15)
1975 Warragul Football Club Colours.PNG John Gallus (Warragul) (28) Peter Pacunskis (Traralgon) (15) P.Boyce (Moe) (20)
1976 EssendonDesign.svg Ray Christine (Bairnsdale) (19) Jack Vardy (Maffra) (17) J.Morrison (St Pat's) (25)
1977 Traralgondesign.png Peter Hall (Traralgon) (14) Jack Vardy (Maffra) (14) C.Dowd (Leongatha)
1978 Jeff Mogel (Morwell) (22) John Kimberley (Yallourn) (18) W.McInnes (Yallourn) (25)
1979 Mafwglfl.PNG Jeff Gieschen (Maffra) (22) Allan Light (Warragul) (24) A.Morrison (Warragul) (24)
1980 Leowglfl.PNG Ian Salmon (Leongatha) (24) Jeff Swenson (Newborough) (24) R.Copeland (Morwell)
1981 Ray Mildenhall (Yallorn/YNth) (24) Jock Eason (Moe) (15) M.Trewella (Warragul) (27)
1982 Jeff Gieschen (Maffra) (27) Kasey Plemper (Moe) (17) G.Scott (Bairnsdale) (27)
David Vogel (Morwell) (27)
1983 Ray Mildenhall (Yallorn/YNth) (24) Greg Roughead (Leongatha) (27) C.Dilettoso (Maffra) (33)
1984 Peter Hall (Traralgon) (27) Gary House (TTU) (17) G.Rankin (Warragul) (22)
1985 Rod Kerr (Morwell) (30)