# Episode Air date Rating Share 18-49 (Rating/Share) Viewers (m) Rank (night) Rank (timeslot) Rank (overall)
1 "Welcome to the Club" October 12, 2007 7.3 13 2.5/8 10.82 #1 #1 #26
2 "Train In Vain" October 19, 2007 6.5 12 2.0/6 9.69 #2 #1 #37
3 "Blind Dates and Bleeding Hearts" October 26, 2007 6.1 11 1.9/6 8.90 #1 #1 #41
4 "Grannies, Guns, Love Mints" November 2, 2007 6.4 11 1.9/6 9.47 #1 #1 #35
5 "Maybe, Baby" November 9, 2007 6.5 11 2.0/6 9.70 #1 #1 #36
6 "Play Through the Pain" November 15, 2007 6.1 10 3.3/9 8.93 #8 #3 #45
7 "The Past Comes Back to Haunt You" November 16, 2007 6.2 11 1.7/5 8.94 #4 #1 #41
8 "No Opportunity Necessary" November 23, 2007 5.3 9 1.6/5 7.76 #3 #1 #45
9 "To Drag & To Hold" December 7, 2007 5.8 10 1.8/5 8.58 #2 #1 #32
10 "FBI Guy" January 4, 2008 5.2 9 1.8/5 7.68 #2 #1 #36
11 "Father's Day" April 29, 2008 5.8 9 1.9/5 8.14 #7 #2 #42
12 "And the Truth Will (Sometimes) Set You Free" May 6, 2008 6.1 10 2.2/6 8.68 #8 #2
13 "Never Tell" May 13, 2008 5.8 10 2.1/6 8.46 #2