Year MVP Defensive Player of the Year Unsung Hero Newcomer of the Year
1993 Canada Patrice Ferri
1994 United States Jean Harbor
1995 Jamaica Lloyd Barker
1996 Canada Paolo Ceccarelli
1997 Canada Mauro Biello
1998 Canada Mauro Biello
1999 N/A
2000 Canada Jim Larkin
2001 Canada Mauro Biello
2002 Cuba Eduardo Sebrango Canada Gabriel Gervais Canada Jason DiTullio Brazil Zé Roberto
2003 Canada Greg Sutton Canada Gabriel Gervais Canada David Fronimadis Canada Martin Nash
2004 Canada Gabriel Gervais Canada Greg Sutton Brazil Zé Roberto Canada Sandro Grande
2005 Canada Mauro Biello Canada Nevio Pizzolitto Argentina Mauricio Vincello Japan Masahiro Fukazawa
2006 Argentina Mauricio Vincello Canada Gabriel Gervais United States Andrew Weber Argentina Leonardo Di Lorenzo
2007 Argentina Leonardo Di Lorenzo Argentina Mauricio Vincello Canada Simon Gatti United States Matt Jordan
2008 United States Matt Jordan Canada Nevio Pizzolitto United States Joey Gjertsen Italy Stefano Pesoli
2009 United States David Testo Canada Nevio Pizzolitto Canada Adam Braz Jamaica Stephen deRoux
2010 France Philippe Billy France Philippe Billy United States Tony Donatelli Canada Ali Gerba
2011 France Hassoun Camara United States Evan Bush Canada Simon Gatti England Ian Westlake / Bosnia and Herzegovina Sinisa Ubiparipovic