Defendant Arrested Charge Result Sentence
John Calvin Bartlett[27] December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty Six years of probation.[28]
Charles Brokaw October 31, 1955 Lewd conduct with a minor Pleaded guilty Six months in prison plus probation.
Vernon Cassel October 31, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty Ten years in prison
Ralph Cooper October 31, 1955 Lewd conduct with a minor Pleaded guilty Life imprisonment. Served nine years.
Melvin Dir January 7, 1956 Lewd conduct with a minor Pleaded guilty Five years in prison, suspended. Later violates probation and is sentenced to seven years.
Charles Herbert Gordon December 11, 1955 Lewd and lascivious conduct Pleaded guilty 15 years in prison
Gordon Larsen December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Tried, found guilty Five years in prison
Paris Martin[note 4] December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Tried, found not guilty[29] None
Joe Moore November 14, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty Seven years in prison. Loses appeal to the Idaho Supreme Court.
Charles Pruett December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty Five years in prison
Reginald Shaffer December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty 15 years in prison
Willard Wilson December 11, 1955 Infamous crimes against nature Pleaded guilty Five years in prison.[27] Loses appeal to the Idaho Supreme Court.