Sheriff Start of term Sheriff Start of term Sheriff Start of term
Josiah Hobart 1683 Abraham Gardiner 1821 Henry Preston 1903
John Mulford 1701 Samuel Smith 1826 John Wells 1906
Hugh Gray 1702 Abraham Gardiner 1829 Charles Platt 1909
John Brush 1710 Richard Smith 1832 Melville Brush 1912
Daniel Youngs 1718 Silas Horton 1835 D. Henry Brown 1913
Samuel Dayton 1723 Samuel Miller 1838 Charles O'Dell 1914
William Sell 1728 David Brush 1841 Amza Biggs 1917
Joseph Smith 1730 Henry Penny 1844 John Kelly 1920
David Corrie 1731 David Rose 1847 Amza Biggs 1923
Jacob Conklin 1734 John Clark 1850 Burton Howe 1926
Thomas Higbe 1740 Samuel Phillips 1855 Ellis Taylor 1929
James Muirson 1774 George Carman 1856 Joseph Warta 1932
Thomas Wickes 1785 Stephen Wilson 1859 William McCollom 1935
Silas Halsey 1787 Daniel Osborn 1862 Jacob Dreyer 1938
Thomas Wickes 1791 George Smith 1868 John Levy 1941
Phinaes Carll 1799 J. Henry Perkins 1871 William McCollom 1942
Josiah Reeve 1803 Egbert Lewis 1874 Charles Dominy 1957
Phinaes Smith 1807 George Cooper 1877 Frank Gross 1962
Josiah Reeve 1808 Robert Petty 1888 Philip Corso 1970
Benjamin Brewster 1810 Selah Brewster 1883 Donald Dilworth 1976
Josiah Reeve 1811 Henry Halsey 1886 John Finnerty 1977
Benjamin Brewster 1812 Robert Petty 1888 Eugene Dooley 1986
Josiah Reeve 1813 A. M. Darling 1891 Patrick Mahoney 1990
Nathaniel Conklin 1814 Benjamin Wood 1897 Alfred C. Tisch 2002
Josiah Reeve 1815 J. Sheridan Wells 1900 Vincent F. DeMarco 2006
Samuel Carll 1819