Rank Name Caps Goals Years
1 Bedford Jezzard 3 6 1954–1955
2 Tommy Taylor 2 4 1956
= Gordon Hill 6 4 1978
= Alan Smith 4 4 1990–1992
5 Jack Rowley 1 3 1949
= Brian Talbot 6 3 1978–1980
= Paul Merson 4 3 1991–1998
= Matthew le Tissier 6 3 1990–1998