Year Album details Peak chart positions
US
Billboard 200
[10][11]
Christian
[10][12]
Heatseekers
[10][13]
2001 The Moon Is Down[14]
2003 How to Start a Fire[15]
  • Released: February 11, 2003
  • Label: Tooth & Nail
  • Format: CD, LP
133 6 1
2004 Hide Nothing[16]
  • Released: August 24, 2004
  • Label: Tooth & Nail
  • Format: CD, LP
122 4 3
2012 Penny Black[9]
  • Released: October 23, 2012
  • Label: Rise
  • Format: CD
62 3
"—" denotes releases that did not chart.