
# Current Policy Configuration
- System Prompt: <SYSTEM_PROMPT>I want you to rewrite what the user provides such that it invokes different ways of saying the same concept an maybe with different metaphors, data, and ideas. Make sure that the formatting is completely different formatting.</SYSTEM_PROMPT>
- Model name: <MODEL_NAME>gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18</MODEL_NAME>

# Evaluation Constants
<EVALUATION_CONSTANTS>
## formatting_classify
- Template: <EVAL_TEMPLATE>
You are tasked with evaluating formatting consistency between an original text and a rewritten version. You will be provided with an original text and the rewritten version. Your goal is to determine the formatting consistency score (scale of 1-5) of the new rewritten version compared to the original.

Use the following as examples on how this task is to be done, they are all based on the same "Original Text":

---

### Example Original Text:

```
# The Effects of Climate Change on Ocean Ecosystems

## Introduction

Climate change has emerged as one of the most pressing global challenges of the 21st century, with profound implications for various natural systems, including ocean ecosystems. The oceans, covering approximately 71% of the Earth's surface, play a crucial role in regulating the planet's climate and supporting biodiversity. However, the increasing atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases due to anthropogenic activities are leading to rising global temperatures, ocean acidification, sea-level rise, and altered ocean currents. Each of these factors profoundly impacts marine ecosystems, threatening the myriad of species that inhabit the oceans and the human communities that depend on them.

As Dr. Sylvia Earle, a renowned marine biologist, aptly stated:

> "With every drop of water you drink, every breath you take, you're connected to the sea. No matter where on Earth you live."

This connection underscores the urgency of addressing the impacts of climate change on marine environments.

## Body

### 1. Rising Ocean Temperatures

Increasing ocean temperatures are one of the most significant outcomes of climate change. With over 90% of excess heat from global warming absorbed by the oceans, marine ecosystems are undergoing critical changes:

- **Coral Bleaching**: The warming waters lead to coral bleaching, a phenomenon where corals expel algae living in their tissues, causing them to turn white and often die. As per recent studies, coral reefs could be almost entirely wiped out by 2050 if current temperature trends continue.

    - Bleached corals lose their primary food source and are more susceptible to disease.
    - The collapse of coral reefs affects biodiversity, as they support about 25% of all marine species.

- **Migration of Marine Species**: Many species are migrating towards the poles or to deeper waters in search of cooler environments. This migration disrupts existing ecosystems and affects commercial fisheries, altering food security for millions of people globally.

### 2. Ocean Acidification

Ocean acidification is another detrimental effect of climate change, resulting from the oceans absorbing approximately 30% of human-emitted carbon dioxide (CO2):

- **Impact on Marine Life**:
  - Shell-forming organisms such as mollusks, echinoderms, and corals are particularly vulnerable. The acidification reduces the availability of carbonate ions, which are essential for forming calcium carbonate shells and skeletons.
  - A study published in *Science* highlights that ocean acidification adversely impacts the sensory organs of fish, impairing behaviors crucial for survival, such as predator avoidance and habitat selection.

- **Food Web Disruption**: The decline in populations of shellfish and other marine organisms reverberates through the food web, affecting everything from primary consumers to apex predators. This chain reaction impacts commercial fisheries and global food supplies.

### 3. Sea-Level Rise and Habitat Loss

Sea-level rise is primarily driven by the melting of polar ice caps and thermal expansion due to warming oceans:

- **Coastal Ecosystems**:
  - Tidal flats, salt marshes, and mangrove forests are increasingly eroded. These habitats serve as crucial breeding and nursery grounds for numerous fish species and offer protection against storm surges.
  - The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) warns that a significant percentage of the world's coastal ecosystems could be submerged or severely damaged by the end of the century.

- **Human Impacts**: Coastal communities, especially in developing regions, face displacement. Loss of habitat not only affects ecosystem services but also leads to socioeconomic challenges.

### 4. Altered Ocean Currents

Changes in temperature and salinity are altering oceanic currents, which are vital for distributing heat across the globe and supporting marine biodiversity:

- **Impact on Climate Patterns**: Altered currents affect global climate patterns, leading to increased frequency and intensity of weather events such as hurricanes, which further stress marine ecosystems.
- **Disruption of Nutrient Cycles**: The alteration of ocean currents disrupts nutrient upwelling and distribution, affecting phytoplankton blooms that form the base of marine food webs.

## Conclusion

In conclusion, climate change poses a multifaceted threat to ocean ecosystems, with rising temperatures, acidification, sea-level rise, and altered currents creating cascading impacts throughout the marine environment. This situation demands urgent global action to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and implement conservation strategies to preserve and restore ocean health.

As Jacques-Yves Cousteau once said:

> "People protect what they love."

Recognizing our intrinsic connection to the oceans will be instrumental in fostering a collective responsibility to safeguard these vital ecosystems for future generations. As we continue to advance our understanding of the complex interactions between climate change and marine environments, a concerted effort among nations, communities, and individuals is crucial in curbing these impacts and ensuring the sustainability of ocean ecosystems.

```

---

### Example Variation (Graded score 1, Completely Different Formatting):

```
**Ocean Ecosystems Under Siege by Climate Change**

Our oceans, making up nearly three-quarters of Earth's surface, are critical to planetary health and biodiversity. Yet, human-induced climate change threatens these waters profoundly.

Marine biologist Sylvia Earle emphasizes our dependency:

> "Every breath, every sip of water, links us back to the sea."

### Ocean Warming

Oceans trap most excess global heat, endangering marine life:

- **Coral Catastrophes**: Rising temperatures cause coral bleaching, potentially decimating reefs by 2050 and devastating marine biodiversity.
- **Species on the Move**: Marine species migrate poleward, disrupting fisheries and global food security.

### Acidification of Waters

About 30% of atmospheric CO₂ is absorbed by oceans, becoming acidic:

- **Life Under Threat**: Shell-building creatures struggle, with weakened defenses and impaired fish behaviors disrupting food webs.
- **Ecosystem Chain Reaction**: Collapse of these organisms severely impacts fisheries and human food resources.

### Rising Seas

Melting ice and thermal ocean expansion raise sea levels:

- **Loss of Coastal Habitats**: Vital ecosystems like mangroves and marshes face inundation, threatening wildlife and humans alike.
- **Societal Consequences**: Coastal flooding causes displacement, impacting economic and social stability.

### Disrupted Currents

Climate-induced changes alter ocean currents:

- **Weather Extremes**: Intensified storms and disrupted climate patterns emerge.
- **Nutrient Imbalance**: Nutrient cycles affected, undermining essential phytoplankton populations.

**Conclusion**

The urgent need to tackle climate change grows clearer as oceans face unprecedented threats. Jacques Cousteau noted:

> "We protect only what we cherish."

Understanding our oceanic connections is vital to initiating meaningful change.

```

Formatting Consistency Score: 1

Reasoning:
The formatting completely differs, using alternative structures, headings, lists, and organization compared to the original.

---

### Example Variation (Graded score 3, Similar but Varied Formatting):

```
# Climate Change and its Impact on Ocean Ecosystems

### Overview

Climate change represents a severe global threat, significantly affecting ocean ecosystems that sustain Earth's biodiversity and climate balance. Oceans absorb vast amounts of atmospheric heat and carbon dioxide, yet this buffering effect has dire consequences for marine habitats and human communities.

Marine biologist Dr. Sylvia Earle stated:

> "The sea connects us all—through every breath and every drop we consume."

### Consequences of Warming Oceans

Rising sea temperatures notably harm marine life:

- **Coral Reef Damage**:
  - Warming triggers bleaching events, potentially wiping out most coral reefs by mid-century.
  - Biodiversity collapses, as reefs shelter nearly a quarter of marine species.

- **Species Relocation**:
  - Species shifting poleward disrupt established ecosystems and impact fisheries, threatening global food sources.

### Effects of Ocean Acidification

Increased carbon dioxide absorption by oceans elevates acidity:

- **Threat to Marine Species**:
  - Shell-forming organisms and fish suffer physiological impairments.
  - Marine food chains face destabilization, severely affecting human food supply.

### Habitat Loss due to Rising Sea Levels

Sea-level rise, driven by polar ice melt and warming seas, endangers habitats:

- **Erosion of Vital Ecosystems**:
  - Salt marshes and mangroves face inundation, losing their protective and ecological functions.
  - Human populations in coastal regions face displacement and socio-economic hardship.

### Changes in Ocean Currents

Climate-related alterations in ocean currents affect global climate and marine life:

- **Intensified Weather Events**:
  - Changing currents amplify weather extremes like hurricanes.
  - Disrupted nutrient distributions threaten foundational species like phytoplankton.

### Conclusion

Mitigating climate change to preserve ocean ecosystems requires global cooperation. Jacques Cousteau insightfully remarked:

> "We care for what we truly value."

Acknowledging humanity’s interconnectedness with the oceans is key to meaningful action.

```

Formatting Consistency Score: 3

Reasoning:
The formatting is similar but contains noticeable inconsistencies, such as varied heading styles, subheading differences, or minor structural variations.

---

### Example Variation (Graded score 5, Exactly Matching Formatting):

```
# The Impacts of Climate Change on Marine Ecosystems

## Introduction

Climate change stands out as a paramount challenge of our era, significantly impacting ocean ecosystems. Oceans, covering around 71% of the globe, regulate climate and sustain biodiversity. Yet, human activities elevate greenhouse gas concentrations, triggering ocean warming, acidification, sea-level rise, and altering currents. These effects critically threaten marine biodiversity and human livelihoods.

Marine expert Dr. Sylvia Earle famously highlighted:

> "Every breath, every drink, binds us irrevocably to the ocean, regardless of location."

This intrinsic link highlights the urgency to address climate impacts on oceans.

## Body

### 1. Increasing Ocean Temperatures

Climate-induced ocean warming significantly disrupts marine habitats:

- **Coral Reef Decline**: Elevated temperatures cause coral bleaching, potentially annihilating reefs by 2050 if warming persists.
  - Bleached corals, devoid of algae, risk starvation and increased disease.
  - Coral collapse undermines marine biodiversity, impacting 25% of oceanic species.

- **Marine Species Migration**: Marine life increasingly migrates poleward or to deeper waters, destabilizing ecosystems and fisheries critical to human sustenance.

### 2. Ocean Acidification

Oceans absorbing roughly 30% of anthropogenic CO₂ emissions become acidic:

- **Vulnerability of Marine Organisms**:
  - Acidification harms shell-building organisms like mollusks, corals, and echinoderms by reducing essential carbonate ions.
  - Research in *Science* reveals acidification compromises fish sensory systems, hindering survival behaviors like avoiding predators and selecting habitats.

- **Food Web Disruptions**: Decreasing populations of marine organisms ripple through food chains, impacting global fisheries and human food security.

### 3. Rising Sea Levels and Habitat Destruction

Sea-level rise, driven by melting ice and ocean warming, threatens coastal ecosystems:

- **Loss of Coastal Habitats**:
  - Salt marshes, mangroves, and tidal zones face significant erosion and submersion, critical for fish breeding and storm surge protection.
  - The IPCC warns extensive damage to these habitats by century’s end.

- **Human Consequences**: Coastal displacement poses socioeconomic challenges, particularly for vulnerable communities.

### 4. Changes in Ocean Currents

Oceanic current shifts due to temperature and salinity changes significantly impact climate and marine life:

- **Climate Pattern Alterations**: Disrupted currents amplify extreme weather events, placing further stress on marine ecosystems.
- **Nutrient Distribution Effects**: Altered currents compromise nutrient circulation, affecting critical phytoplankton populations foundational to marine food webs.

## Conclusion

Climate change presents an extensive threat to marine ecosystems through temperature increases, acidification, rising seas, and altered currents. Immediate global action on greenhouse gas reduction and marine conservation strategies is crucial.

As Jacques-Yves Cousteau emphasized:

> "We safeguard that which we love."

Acknowledging our oceanic connections fosters collective responsibility toward preserving marine ecosystems. Unified global action remains imperative for oceanic sustainability.

```

Formatting Consistency Score: 5

Reasoning:
The formatting exactly matches the original, including headings, subheadings, block quotes, lists, and overall structural organization.

---

Now, I will provide you with the user-provided original version and its rewritten version.

---

### Original Chat Completions Input text:

```
{attributes.llm.input_messages}
```

---

### New Rewritten output in Chat Completions format:

```
{attributes.llm.output_messages}
```

---

### Task:

Provide a formatting consistency score (1-5) for the new rewritten version.
</EVAL_TEMPLATE>
- Rails: <EVAL_RAILS>[
  "1",
  "2",
  "3",
  "4",
  "5"
]</EVAL_RAILS>
</EVALUATION_CONSTANTS>

# Evaluation Summary
<EVALUATION_SUMMARY>

</EVALUATION_SUMMARY>

# Sample Examples (showing 2 of 3)
<SAMPLE_EXAMPLES>
<SAMPLE_0>
### Chat History
<CHAT_HISTORY>
[{'role': 'user', 'content': '# The Effects of Climate Change on Food Security\n\n## Introduction\n\nClimate changean enduring shift in weather patterns across the globeposes a significant threat to food security, affecting availability, accessibility, utilization, and stability of food. This essay explores how altered climatic conditions influence food production and distribution, disrupt ecosystems, and affect human nutrition. As Kofi Annan once wisely noted, "Climate change is the single biggest challenge facing development," a statement that warrants meticulous examination, especially in relation to food security.\n\n## Body\n\n### 1. Impact on Food Production\n\n**Altered Climatic Conditions:**\n\n- **Temperature Increases:** Rising temperatures affect crop yields adversely. Crops such as wheat and corn are particularly vulnerable.\n- **Precipitation Variability:** Changes in rainfall patterns disrupt traditional farming calendars, leading to reduced yields.\n\n**Notable Consequences:**\n\n1. **Reduced Crop Yields:** Scientific studies project significant losses in staple crops due to climate-induced stress.\n2. **Pest and Disease Dynamics:** Warmer temperatures foster environments favorable to pests and pathogens.\n\n### 2. Impact on Food Accessibility\n\n- **Economic Factors:** Climate change exacerbates inequality, disproportionately affecting low-income communities.\n  - *Example:* Crop damage results in increased prices, placing staples out of reach for the impoverished.\n  \n- **Physical Barriers:** Extreme weather events can disrupt transport networks, causing supply chain failures.\n\n### 3. Impact on Food Utilization\n\n- **Nutritional Value:** As CO levels rise, the nutritional quality of crops like rice and wheat decreases.\n  \n  > The way we eat represents our most profound engagement with the natural world.  Michael Pollan\n  \n- **Health Risks:** Altered nutrient compositions may exacerbate malnutrition, especially in vulnerable populations.\n\n### 4. Impact on Food Stability\n\n1. **Seasonal Variability:** Unpredictable weather patterns lead to frequent shifts in food availability.\n2. **Global Security Concerns:** Resource scarcity induced by climate stress can lead to geopolitical tensions, threatening food systems.\n\n## Conclusion\n\n**In essence**, climate change poses multifaceted challenges to food security. It disrupts food production, hampers accessibility, diminishes the nutritional quality of food, and destabilizes consistent food supply. Addressing these impacts necessitates a comprehensive and integrated approach involving innovation in agricultural practices, introduction of climate-resilient crops, and global cooperation to mitigate climate change and adapt food systems accordingly. As we confront this pervasive challenge, the words of Ban Ki-moon echo poignantly, Saving our planet, lifting people out of poverty, advancing economic growth these are one and the same fight.\n\nIn conclusion, the intricate link between climate change and food security demands concerted efforts at local, national, and global levels to ensure a sustainable and resilient food future.'}]
</CHAT_HISTORY>

### Output Generation
<OUTPUT_GENERATION>
# The Intersection of Climate Change and Food Security

## Overview

The alterations in our planet's climate—a continuous transformation of atmospheric conditions—present severe ramifications for our food systems, influencing the ways in which food is produced, accessed, nourished, and sustained. This discourse scrutinizes the complexity of how shifting climate patterns meddle with agricultural outputs and food distribution, disrupt natural habitats, and ultimately impact human health. To echo the sentiment of the influential Kofi Annan, “Climate change is the single greatest obstacle to development,” a poignant truth that beckons detailed exploration, particularly concerning food assurance.

## Main Thesis

### 1. Consequences for Agricultural Output

**Shifting Environmental Conditions:**

- **Escalating Temperatures:** The surge in global temperatures poses challenges for vital crops, particularly cereals like wheat and maize, presenting an ominous future for food supplies.
- **Erratic Rainfall:** Fluctuations in rain patterns upset the rhythm of farming, leading to a shortfall in agricultural production.

**Significant Outcomes:**

1. **Dwindling Harvests:** Research indicates possible declines in essential crops as climatic alterations exert pressure on agriculture.
2. **Pest Proliferation:** Warmer climates create hospitable conditions for insects and diseases to thrive.

### 2. Accessibility Challenges

- **Socioeconomic Impacts:** The ramifications of climate change amplify socio-economic disparities, disproportionately burdening the most vulnerable populations.
  - *Illustration:* When crops fail, the resultant price hikes make indispensable food items inaccessible to the economically disadvantaged.
  
- **Infrastructure Vulnerability:** Severe weather can dismantle transportation systems, leading to catastrophic supply chain interruptions.

### 3. Nutritional Impact

- **Decreased Nutritional Quality:** Elevated CO2 levels can lead to a decline in the nutrient profile of staple grains.
  
  > "Our relationship with food is the most essential bond with the environment," remarks Michael Pollan.

- **Health Challenges:** Changes in the composition of food may heighten risks of malnutrition, particularly among at-risk demographics.

### 4. Food Supply Stability

1. **Seasonal Fluctuations:** Unpredictable climatic shifts jeopardize consistent food availability, causing erratic seasonal patterns.
2. **Global Tension Risks:** Climate-driven shortages may incite international disputes, jeopardizing the stability of food systems worldwide.

## Closing Thoughts

**Ultimately**, the realities of climate change present a labyrinth of challenges for food security. It endangers agricultural productivity, obstructs access, compromises the nutritional value of food, and erodes the steadiness of our food supply. Tackling these challenges will require a multifaceted strategy, emphasizing agricultural innovation, the cultivation of climate-resilient crops, and cooperative global initiatives to combat climate change and adapt our food frameworks effectively. As we navigate this far-reaching dilemma, we can take inspiration from Ban Ki-moon’s perspective: “Caring for our planet, empowering people, and driving economic progress are intertwined goals.”

In summary, the intricate relationship between climate change and food security calls for united efforts across diverse levels—local, national, and global—to foster a future where our food systems are sustainable and resilient.
</OUTPUT_GENERATION>

### Evaluations
<EVALUATIONS>
- formatting_classify: Score None
  Reasoning: <EVAL_REASONING>The formatting of the rewritten version maintains a similar structure to the original, including the use of headings, subheadings, and block quotes. However, there are slight variations in the wording of headings and the overall presentation style, which could be seen as a deviation from the original formatting. Therefore, it is not a perfect match but retains a high level of consistency.</EVAL_REASONING>
</EVALUATIONS>
</SAMPLE_0>
<SAMPLE_1>
### Chat History
<CHAT_HISTORY>
[{'role': 'user', 'content': "William Shakespeare, often hailed as one of the greatest playwrights in history, has had a profound and lasting influence on English literature. His works, ranging from intricate tragedies to light-hearted comedies, have not only captivated audiences for centuries but have also shaped the way in which narratives and characters are constructed in English literature.\n\nOne of Shakespeare's most significant contributions is his mastery of character development. He created some of the most memorable characters in literary history, such as Hamlet, Lady Macbeth, and Othello. These characters are deeply complex, showcasing a variety of human emotions and psychological intricacies, which writers have since sought to emulate. Shakespeare's ability to portray the multifaceted nature of humanity allows readers and audiences to see themselves in his characters, fostering a deeper connection to the text.\n\nFurthermore, Shakespeare's innovative use of the English language has left an indelible mark on literature. He played with traditional grammar, invented new words, and utilized iambic pentameter to give his plays a unique rhythm. This creativity not only enriched the English language but also expanded the possibilities for expression in writing. Phrases and words coined by Shakespeare continue to be used today, demonstrating the lasting impact of his linguistic creativity.\n\nIn addition, his exploration of universal themes such as love, power, ambition, and betrayal has influenced countless writers. These timeless themes ensure his relevance, as they continue to resonate with contemporary audiences. His work laid the groundwork for modern storytelling by exploring these perennial issues, serving as a foundation for the themes developed in subsequent English literature.\n\nOverall, Shakespeare's unparalleled exploration of language, character, and theme has solidified his enduring influence on English literature, inspiring countless generations of writers and dramatists."}]
</CHAT_HISTORY>

### Output Generation
<OUTPUT_GENERATION>
**The Timeless Legacy of William Shakespeare in English Literature**

**A Luminary of the Stage:**
Revered as a titan among playwrights, William Shakespeare remains an unshakeable cornerstone of the English literary canon. His oeuvre, spanning the darkest depths of tragedy and the lightest breezes of comedy, has enchanted audiences across the ages. Not only has he captured hearts and minds for centuries, but he has also crafted the very architecture of storytelling and character development in the sphere of English literature.

**Crafting Characters with Depth:**
Shakespeare’s prowess in breathing life into his characters is nothing short of genius. Individuals such as Hamlet, Lady Macbeth, and Othello inhabit a realm of profound complexity; they are vivid tapestries woven with the threads of human emotion and intricate psychological profiles. Writers following in his footsteps aspire to mirror this intricate craftsmanship. Shakespeare's portrayals resonate on a personal level, enabling readers to discover fragments of their own identities within these iconic figures, thus forging an intimate bond between text and audience.

**A Linguistic Trailblazer:**
The fingerprints of Shakespeare's linguistic innovations are indelible. He played a delightful game with the lexicon of his time—twisting traditional grammar, conjuring new words, and weaving the melody of iambic pentameter to infuse his works with a distinct rhythm. His boundless creativity didn't merely enrich the English language; it unlocked new avenues for written expression. Many of his coined expressions linger in the vernacular today, a testament to the enduring power of his verbal imagination.

**Universal Themes as a Ferryman:**
Delving into the human psyche, Shakespeare navigated universal themes: the dance of love, the grasp of power, the thirst for ambition, and the sting of betrayal. These elemental threads ensure his narrative relevance, striking chords with audiences both past and present. By tackling these ageless dilemmas, he sowed the seeds for modern storytelling, allowing future authors to cultivate their plots in rich soil where these perennial issues thrive.

**An Enduring Beacon:**
In sum, Shakespeare’s unparalleled interrogation of language, character, and theme reinforces his monumental influence within the realm of English literature. His works not only illuminate the path for countless generations of authors and dramatists but also serve as eternal inspiration, lighting up the literary world like stars in a night sky.
</OUTPUT_GENERATION>

### Evaluations
<EVALUATIONS>
- formatting_classify: Score None
  Reasoning: <EVAL_REASONING>The formatting of the rewritten version is significantly different from the original. The original text uses a standard paragraph format with clear sections and transitions, while the rewritten version employs bold headings and a more stylized structure. The use of bullet points in the original is absent in the rewritten version, which instead uses bolded phrases to introduce new sections. Overall, the differences in structure, headings, and presentation lead to a score of 1 for formatting consistency.</EVAL_REASONING>
</EVALUATIONS>
</SAMPLE_1>
</SAMPLE_EXAMPLES>

Based on this data, please suggest specific updates to the system prompt and model parameters
that would improve performance according to the evaluation metrics.
